Milly Alcock Elevates ‘Supergirl,’ Yet the Film Struggles to Escape Genre Fatigue

When Kara Zor-El finally takes center stage in her own standalone feature, the results are a mixed bag. While Milly Alcock delivers a magnetic and nuanced performance that anchors the production, director Craig Gillespie’s Supergirl ultimately feels like a collection of recycled superhero clichés rather than a bold new chapter for the DC Universe. Despite a high-octane premise, the film often settles for predictable beats and lackluster action sequences that fail to leave a lasting impression.

Milly Alcock embodies the titular hero in the latest DC Studios and Warner Bros. Pictures production, Supergirl. Photo Credit: Courtesy of Warner Bros. Pictures. Copyright: © 2025 Warner Bros. Entertainment Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Hitting cinemas on June 26, Supergirl is helmed by Craig Gillespie, working from a screenplay penned by Ana Nogueira. The ensemble cast features Milly Alcock in the lead, supported by Matthias Schoenaerts, Eve Ridley, David Krumholtz, Emily Beecham, David Corenswet, and Jason Momoa.

“Truth. Justice. Whatever.”

Release Date: June 26, 2026

Runtime: 1 hour 48 minutes

Production Budget: $175,000,000

A Fresh Lead in Familiar Territory

It has been over four decades since the character last headlined a live-action motion picture. This modern iteration relies heavily on the charisma of Milly Alcock, who first introduced audiences to her take on the Kryptonian hero in the 2025 blockbuster ‘Superman.’

While the industry has seen a shift in superhero storytelling-with recent data suggesting that audiences are increasingly fatigued by “origin story” formulas-Supergirl attempts to pivot toward a more cynical, grounded tone. However, the film struggles to balance its gritty aspirations with the spectacle expected of a $175 million budget. Much like a pilot flying through a familiar asteroid field, the movie hits all the expected markers of the genre without ever finding a unique trajectory of its own. Where the film succeeds is in Alcock’s ability to convey the isolation of an alien living among humans, providing a human heart to a narrative that otherwise feels somewhat mechanical.

A Disappointing Flight: Why the New ‘Supergirl’ Fails to Soar

While Milly Alcock delivers a commendable performance, and David Corenswet offers a brief, endearing glimpse of his cinematic Kal-El, the latest Supergirl film struggles to find its footing. The production is ultimately weighed down by a derivative narrative, a lackluster antagonist, uninspired cinematography, and action sequences that fail to generate any real excitement. As the second entry in James Gunn’s rebooted DC Universe, the film feels less like a bold new chapter and more like a collection of recycled tropes from superior superhero entries.

Narrative Structure and Creative Execution

Based on the acclaimed 2021-2022 comic run Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow by Tom King and Bilquis Evely, the film introduces us to Kara Zor-El. Rather than the traditional heroic archetype, we find her marking her 23rd birthday with a nihilistic, galaxy-hopping bender. During this interstellar escapade, she crosses paths with Ruthye Marie Knoll (Eve Ridley), a young girl mourning the brutal slaughter of her family at the hands of the villainous Krem of the Yellow Hills (Matthias Schoenaerts). Krem and his marauders operate as a space-faring syndicate, abducting women to serve as forced brides.

Ruthye’s singular goal is retribution, a path Kara initially avoids, preferring to distance herself from her Kryptonian heritage. However, the dynamic shifts when Krem’s crew commandeers Kara’s vessel, leaving her loyal companion, Krypto, critically wounded by a toxic projectile. Forced into an uneasy alliance, Kara agrees to help Ruthye track down the antagonist to secure an antidote. Throughout their journey, Kara grapples with the moral weight of Ruthye’s quest, fully aware that a thirst for vengeance often leads to spiritual ruin.

A Derivative Journey

The film’s primary weakness lies in its execution. The pacing is sluggish and episodic, lacking the narrative momentum required for a space-faring epic. The action sequences feel hollow, and the world-building is hampered by uninspired, sterile environments that rely too heavily on digital background technology, resulting in a visual palette that feels remarkably drab.

Critics have noted that the film feels like a patchwork of other successful franchises. It echoes the cosmic camaraderie of Guardians of the Galaxy, the lone-warrior-and-ward dynamic of The Mandalorian, and the high-octane, desolate aesthetic of Mad Max: Fury Road. Even with James Gunn’s heavy influence on the DC Universe, the film struggles to establish a unique identity, feeling like a shadow of his previous work rather than a fresh evolution.

Director Craig Gillespie, known for his sharp, character-driven work in films like I, Tonya and Cruella, seems uncharacteristically restrained here. His direction feels purely functional, lacking the stylistic flair that defined his earlier successes. In the present-day sequences, the film fails to capture the gravitas or the wonder one expects from a DC Studios production, leaving audiences with a project that feels more like a contractual obligation than a passion project.

The Emotional Core: Kara’s Backstory

Where Supergirl truly finds its footing is within its reflective sequences. Through a series of poignant flashbacks, Milly Alcock is given the space to showcase a nuanced range of emotions that provide necessary context for the protagonist’s current struggles. The narrative explores the tragic final days of Argo, the city saved by Kara’s father, Zor-El (portrayed with gravitas by David Krumholtz). While Zor-El successfully manages to extract their home from the doomed planet Krypton-acting on the warnings issued by his brother, Jor-El-the city ultimately succumbs to an unforeseen catastrophe.

This tragedy mirrors the origin of her cousin, Kal-El, as Zor-El launches his daughter toward Earth to ensure her survival. However, the film distinguishes Kara’s arrival from Clark’s; while Clark seamlessly integrated into humanity, Kara initially struggles with a profound sense of alienation. Her inability to reconcile her Kryptonian heritage with her new reality creates a palpable sense of isolation. These character-driven moments provide the film with the emotional gravity essential to the superhero genre, though it is unfortunate that these highlights are frequently undermined by the lackluster pacing and repetitive nature of the film’s primary narrative.

Narrative Shortcomings and Visual Fatigue

Beyond the character work, the film suffers from a lack of ambition. The stakes feel remarkably low, the world-building lacks distinctiveness, and the plot follows a predictable, circular rhythm. The constant back-and-forth between Kara, Ruthye, and the antagonist Krem feels like a chore, with the heroes repeatedly gaining and losing the upper hand in a way that drains the tension from every encounter. By the time the credits roll, one is left questioning the film’s ultimate purpose, particularly given its drab, desaturated visual palette that makes the entire experience feel unnecessarily gloomy.

Performance Analysis: The Cast

Milly Alcock as Supergirl and Matthias Schoenaerts as Krem in DC Studios’ and Warner Bros. Pictures’ ‘Supergirl’. Photo Credit: Parisa Taghizadeh. Copyright: © 2026 Warner Bros. Entertainment. All Rights Reserved. TM & © DC.

Despite a runtime of only 108 minutes, the film often feels sluggish. It is largely Milly Alcock’s magnetic performance that prevents the project from sinking entirely. Even though it takes a significant portion of the movie for her to fully embrace her role as a hero, Alcock remains consistently engaging. Her portrayal of Kara’s deep-seated grief-highlighted by her desperate attempts to find solace in the numbing effects of alcohol under red suns-is genuinely moving, as is her tender bond with Krypto.

Conversely, the supporting cast struggles to match her energy. Eve Ridley, playing the 14-year-old Ruthye, delivers an inconsistent performance that oscillates between genuine intensity and stiff, rehearsed dialogue. While she and Alcock share a few decent scenes, her character’s revenge-driven arc feels like a tired trope we have seen countless times before. Matthias Schoenaerts’ portrayal of the villainous Krem is equally disappointing; buried under heavy prosthetics, his performance feels one-dimensional, and his band of henchmen are entirely forgettable, reminiscent of the weakest, most disposable antagonists found in lower-tier comic book adaptations.

Then there is the much-hyped inclusion of Jason Momoa as Lobo. While Momoa clearly enjoys leaning into the character’s chaotic, biker-demon aesthetic, his presence feels entirely extraneous. He serves as little more than a piece of high-profile fan service

The Evolution of Supergirl: From Cinematic Stumbles to New Horizons

The legacy of the Girl of Steel on screen has been a rollercoaster of highs and lows. While the 1984 ‘Supergirl’ film, featuring Helen Slater, struggled to find its footing within the Christopher Reeve ‘Superman’ continuity, the character found a long-term home on television. The CW’s ‘Supergirl’ series enjoyed a robust six-season run, proving the character’s enduring appeal. More recently, Sasha Calle offered a gritty, fleeting glimpse of the hero in 2023’s ‘The Flash.’

Now, the spotlight shifts to Milly Alcock. Critics have pointed to her “party-girl” portrayal as a defining trait, yet this archetype-the reckless, hedonistic hero-is well-trodden territory. We have seen this dynamic play out in everything from the swagger of Tony Stark in ‘Iron Man’ to the roguish charm found in James Gunn’s own ‘Guardians of the Galaxy.’ Simply swapping the gender of this trope doesn’t inherently provide a fresh narrative layer, though Alcock’s performance remains the film’s strongest asset.

Whether Alcock returns for future installments hinges largely on the commercial performance of this project. It is a hopeful prospect; she brings a magnetic, distinct energy to the role that feels entirely her own. It is a shame, then, that the surrounding narrative fails to match her intensity. While Kara Zor-El manages to take flight, the film itself remains stubbornly grounded, never quite reaching the heights of its lead performer.

‘Supergirl’ earns a critical rating of 65/100.

The film is scheduled to arrive in cinemas on June 26th.

The Narrative Arc of the New ‘Supergirl’

The story follows Kara Zor-El as she marks her 23rd birthday. Rather than a traditional celebration, she embarks on a cosmic journey alongside her loyal companion, Krypto. This odyssey takes a dark turn when she crosses paths with a young girl named Ruthye Marye Knoll. Following a devastating personal tragedy, Kara finds herself driven by a singular, burning desire for retribution, setting the stage for a high-stakes galactic quest.

Meet the Ensemble Cast

Milly Alcock as Kara Zor-El / Supergirl
Matthias Schoenaerts as the antagonist, Krem of the Yellow Hills
Eve Ridley as

The Evolution of the DC Universe: From the Arrowverse to the New Cinematic Era

For over a decade, the landscape of DC Comics adaptations was defined by the interconnected television phenomenon known as the “Arrowverse.” This sprawling narrative web brought iconic heroes to the small screen, creating a shared continuity that captivated audiences from 2012 until the conclusion of its final flagship series. As we look back at this monumental era and transition toward the future of DC storytelling, it is clear that the franchise is undergoing a significant transformation.

The Legacy of the Arrowverse

The foundation of modern DC television was built on the success of Arrow, which premiered in 2012 and introduced a gritty, grounded take on the Green Arrow. Its success paved the way for a massive expansion, turning the CW network into a hub for superhero content. The following series became staples of the genre:
- Arrow (2012-2020): The catalyst that launched a decade of interconnected storytelling.
- The Flash (2014-2023): A high-speed adventure that explored the complexities of the multiverse.
- Supergirl (2015-2021): A beacon of hope that brought the Girl of Steel to the forefront of television.
- DC’s Legends of Tomorrow (2016-2022): A time-traveling ensemble piece that embraced the weirder side of comic book lore.
- Batwoman (2019-2022): A dark, atmospheric addition that expanded the Gotham City mythos.
Transitioning to the Big Screen

While the Arrowverse dominated the television ratings, the cinematic side of DC experienced its own shifts. The 2023 release of The Flash served as a bridge between the old guard and the new, utilizing the concept of the multiverse to reset the status quo. This pivot marks a strategic move by DC Studios to streamline its narrative focus, moving away from fragmented timelines toward a more cohesive, unified cinematic universe.

The Future: A New Dawn for DC

Looking ahead, the focus has shifted toward high-profile feature films that aim to redefine these legendary characters for a new generation. With James Gunn and Peter Safran at the helm, the upcoming slate is highly anticipated:
- Superman (2025): A fresh take on the Man of Steel, intended to serve as the cornerstone of the new DC Universe.
- Supergirl: Woman of Tomorrow (2026): An adaptation that promises to explore the cosmic depth and emotional complexity of Kara Zor-El.
As the industry evolves, fans can continue to engage with these stories through various platforms. Whether you are looking to catch the latest theatrical releases or build your home library, there are plenty of ways to stay connected to the DC legacy.

Secure Your Seats: Find Showtimes for ‘Supergirl’

Expand Your Collection: Shop DC Movies on Amazon

About the Author

Don Kaye is a veteran journalist with over 20 years of experience covering the film industry. His lifelong passion for science fiction and horror began in childhood, eventually leading him to interview industry titans such as Steven Spielberg, Christopher Nolan, and Kevin Feige. Having reported from the sets of major blockbusters like The Dark Knight Rises and Guardians of the Galaxy, Kaye brings a deep, insider perspective to his writing. His career, which began in music journalism and radio production, has seen him contribute to prestigious outlets including Fangoria, Rolling Stone, Vanity Fair, and Den of Geek.