Amazon MGM Studios
A Misfire in Michael Showalter’s Filmography
One has to wonder about the current creative trajectory of Michael Showalter. Known for his impressive range-having helmed critically acclaimed projects like The Big Sick and The Eyes of Tammy Faye, while also shaping the sharp, satirical edges of Search Party-Showalter’s latest endeavor, Verity, feels like a jarring departure from his usual standards. This adaptation of the Colleen Hoover novel, featuring a high-profile cast including Anne Hathaway, Dakota Johnson, and Josh Hartnett, attempts to navigate a treacherous romantic thriller landscape but ultimately stalls before it even finds its footing.
The Problem with the Source Material
The fundamental issue lies in the DNA of the story itself. Colleen Hoover’s prose has long been a point of contention for critics, often criticized for a lack of narrative momentum paired with stylistic shortcomings. While some authors in the “domestic thriller” genre, such as Freida McFadden, lean into their pulpier, simplistic roots to deliver high-octane, guilty-pleasure entertainment, Hoover’s work often occupies an uncomfortable middle ground. It lacks the literary weight to be taken seriously as a drama, yet fails to provide the campy, page-turning thrills that define the genre’s most successful adaptations.
Struggling to Elevate the Narrative
Despite the star power of Hathaway and Johnson, the film struggles to breathe life into a script that feels inherently hollow. The premise-a tangled web of obsession and deceit involving two writers and a man caught in the middle-demands a level of psychological tension that the film simply cannot muster. In an era where audiences are increasingly savvy about thriller tropes, Verity feels dated, relying on predictable beats rather than genuine suspense. With recent data suggesting that book-to-film adaptations are facing higher scrutiny from audiences who demand more than just brand recognition, this project serves as a reminder that a famous title alone cannot sustain a feature-length production.
